Political speech, above all other sorts of speech, is what the 1st Amendment was enacted to protect.
This morning I took a call from Mr. Thomasson, Democratic commissioner candidate for District 3 in Elbert County. Mr. Thomasson is a principal content provider on the website Abe21.net. The content on Abe21.net is mostly about local political issues. I read Abe21.net and when I take issue with something printed there, I make an image record of the writing, show it here on this website in full context so people can read what has motivated me to comment, and then make my comment. Moreover, I have published, verbatim, all comments received about items on this blog.
In the early days of this blog I tried referencing the content on Abe21.net with hotlinks, but the content would invariably be moved and the links would become useless. Now I include the political content on this website that I respond to in picture image format because I want there to be no confusion about the source of the content being Abe21.net, I want there to be no claim that something was taken out of context, and I want the writings preserved for historical reference. Full context and explicit attribution remain available on this blog after they have been deleted from Abe21.net. Since many of the political issues on Abe21.net and here have long life spans of their own, I believe this is an important service to the community.
A couple weeks ago, Mr. Thomasson informed me that it was his policy to not respond to issues raised on this blog because he did not want to legitimize the debates raised here. Well ideas, whether or not Mr. Thomasson chooses to debate them, have consequences — a fact of which Mr. Thomasson is evidently aware since today he threatened me with a copyright action.
Now, if Abe21.net was not political speech, or if Abe21.net was not freely available, or if Abe21.net had a requirement for some sort of consideration to be read, or if Abe21.net preserved its political speech to enable reasonable rebuttal, or if my inclusion of Abe21.net content was in any way plagiarism, then I would gladly return to using hotlinks to reference the debatable political content there.
More interesting however is that while Mr. Thomasson does not consider issues raised on this blog to be worth discussion, he evidently thinks they are worth trying to chill.
elbertcounty.net/blog – speaking for the ideas, holding political candidates accountable.
Facilitating speech, not chilling it.